Hesitant, Hopeful

I need some feedback here. Somehow, I managed to completely screw up my previous theme. I have no idea how it happened, but it did and there's no fixing it. Not awesome. So, I'm looking for something new, not because I necessarily wanted to, but out of duress. Broken theme is broken.

So, what do you think of this theme? It's neat, but is it functional? Help me out here. Can you easily find the comment button? Is the theme easy to navigate?

I like how clutter-free and simple it is, while still being really unique. Unfortunately, I can't decide if it's too unique. Let me know.

UPDATE:

I changed the theme that I was originally seeking feedback on, but I'd still like to hear how you like this one. I'm looking for something that suits me. So, who knows how long it'll be here. I really like it, though. It's still simple, but it's more functional than the previous.

If you're interested in seeing the previous theme, the one I was on the fence about, it's this one: http://carolinethemes.com/2012/11/04/spun/ (Which I still love, by the way).

Thanks.